Roth Conversion Calculator
Compare converting part or all of a traditional IRA to a Roth against leaving it alone. Enter the amount you would convert, your expected growth, the tax rate you would pay now, and the rate you expect at withdrawal. The calculator assumes conversion taxes are paid with outside cash, not from the IRA itself.
Conversion amount
Growth and timing
Tax rates
Formula used: Roth value = amount × (1 + r)n. Traditional after-tax value = amount × (1 + r)n × (1 − retirement rate). Conversion wins when the rate you pay now is below the rate you would pay later.
A Roth conversion sounds simple: you move money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA and pay tax on it now. The hard part is knowing whether that trade is actually worth it, because the answer depends on tax rates, time, and a few rules most people never hear about.
This guide walks through the full decision, step by step. You will learn what a conversion really does to your money, how to compare converting against doing nothing, and how to use the Roth Conversion Calculator to run your own numbers in under a minute.
By the end, you will be able to tell whether converting saves you money or quietly costs you more, and you will know the common traps that turn a good conversion into a regret.
What a Roth Conversion Really Does
A traditional IRA holds pre-tax money. You got a deduction when you contributed, the money grows without yearly taxes, and you pay ordinary income tax on every dollar you withdraw.
A Roth IRA works in reverse. You pay tax up front, and then the money grows and comes out completely tax-free, as long as you follow the rules. A conversion moves money from the first kind of account to the second.
The price of that move is immediate. The amount you convert counts as ordinary income in the year you convert it, and you owe tax at your current marginal rate. The reward is future: decades of tax-free growth and withdrawals.
How to Use the Roth Conversion Calculator
Enter the amount you would convert, your expected annual return, and the number of years until you plan to withdraw the money. Then enter the marginal tax rate you would pay on the conversion today and the rate you expect in retirement.
The calculator grows the converted amount at your assumed return, computes what the traditional balance would be worth after retirement taxes, and shows which path leaves you ahead. It assumes you pay the conversion tax with outside cash, which is the standard way to compare.
Try several combinations. Change the retirement tax rate by a few points and watch the verdict flip. That sensitivity is the whole point: the decision hinges on rates, not on guesswork.
The Core Comparison Formula
The math behind a conversion is a single comparison. Grow the money, then tax it, and see which ending balance is bigger.
The formula is:
Roth ending value = converted amount × (1 + annual return)years
And the alternative:
Traditional after-tax value = converted amount × (1 + annual return)years × (1 − retirement tax rate)
Notice the growth is identical in both cases. The only thing that differs is when and at what rate the tax is taken. If your rate now is lower than your rate later, converting wins. If the rates are equal, it is a wash. If your rate now is higher, converting loses.
Worked Example: Converting in a Low-Income Year
First, the setup. Maya is 45, converts $100,000 during a low-income year, pays 12% now, expects 7% annual returns, plans to withdraw in 20 years, and expects to face 24% in retirement.
The tax bill now is $100,000 × 0.12 = $12,000, paid from her savings. The converted $100,000 grows for 20 years: $100,000 × 1.0720 = $386,968, all of it tax-free.
Then, the alternative. If she leaves the money traditional, it still grows to $386,968, but she pays 24% at withdrawal: $386,968 × 0.76 = $294,096.
The net advantage is $386,968 × (0.24 − 0.12) = $46,436 in favor of the Roth. Paying 12% now to avoid 24% later wins by a wide margin, because the 12-point rate gap compounds over 20 years.
Worked Example: The Losing Case at Equal Rates
Next, consider David, who converts $80,000 at a 22% rate and expects to be in the same 22% bracket in retirement. Growth is 7%, horizon is 15 years.
His tax bill is $80,000 × 0.22 = $17,600. The Roth grows to $80,000 × 1.0715 = $220,722.
The traditional path grows to the same $220,722, then pays 22%: $220,722 × 0.78 = $172,163.
Wait, that looks like the Roth wins by $48,559. It does not, because David paid $17,600 of outside money that would otherwise have grown. That $17,600 invested at 7% for 15 years becomes $17,600 × 1.0715 = $48,559, exactly canceling the gain. At equal rates the conversion is a true wash, which the calculator confirms when both rates match.
Worked Example: Staggered Partial Conversions
Sofia is 60, retired early, with two low-income years before Social Security starts. Instead of converting $150,000 at once and landing in the 32% bracket, she converts $50,000 per year for three years, staying in the 12% bracket.
Year one: $50,000 converted, $6,000 tax. Year two: another $50,000, another $6,000. Year three: the same. Total tax: $18,000, or 12% of the $150,000.
Had she converted it all in one year, much of it would have been taxed at 24% or 32%, costing roughly $36,000 or more. Staggering the conversion across low-income years cut her tax bill roughly in half.
The lesson is that the size of each conversion matters as much as the decision itself. Filling up a low bracket year after year is one of the most powerful conversion strategies available.
Worked Example: Paying the Tax Bill From Cash
Compare two versions of the same conversion. Tom converts $60,000 at 22% and pays the $13,200 tax from a savings account. Lisa converts $60,000 and has the tax withheld from the conversion, so only $46,800 actually lands in her Roth.
Tom's Roth gets the full $60,000 working. After 20 years at 7%, that is $60,000 × 1.0720 = $232,181 of tax-free money.
Lisa's Roth starts with $46,800, which grows to $181,061. She also lost the $13,200 that could have compounded. The gap after 20 years is about $51,120.
This is why every serious conversion analysis assumes outside funds pay the tax. Withholding from the conversion shrinks the Roth and, if you are under 59 and a half, can even trigger a 10% early withdrawal penalty on the withheld portion.
Why Paying the Tax From Outside Funds Matters
When you pay conversion tax from a taxable savings account, you are effectively moving that money into the Roth's tax-free shelter too. The dollars that would have been eaten by taxes on interest and dividends each year now compound untouched.
This is the hidden second benefit of a conversion. The headline benefit is the rate arbitrage, paying 12% now instead of 22% later. The quiet benefit is sheltering the tax payment itself from future taxation.
If you cannot pay the tax from outside funds, run the numbers with the smaller Roth balance before deciding. The calculator's verdict changes noticeably when the conversion is reduced by withholding.
The Five-Year Clock on Each Conversion
Every Roth conversion starts its own five-year clock. If you withdraw converted principal before five years pass and you are under 59 and a half, the 10% early withdrawal penalty applies to the converted amount.
The clock starts on January 1 of the year you convert, so a December conversion is nearly a year ahead. Each conversion has its own separate clock, which matters if you convert in multiple years.
After 59 and a half, the penalty disappears entirely. And once any Roth IRA of yours has been open five years and you are 59 and a half, qualified distributions, including earnings, come out tax-free with no further clocks to watch.
Tax Brackets and Marginal Rate Changes
Your marginal rate is what matters, not your effective rate. A conversion stacks on top of your other income for the year, so the first dollars may be taxed at 12% while the last are taxed at 24% or higher.
This is why partial conversions are so popular. You convert exactly enough to fill your current bracket without spilling into the next one, then stop. The calculator shows the average effect, but the real planning happens bracket by bracket.
Watch for years when your income dips: early retirement before pensions start, a sabbatical, a job change, or the years between retirement and required minimum distributions. Those are the golden windows for conversions.
IRMAA Surcharges and RMD Pressure
Two forces push many retirees toward conversions whether they like it or not. The first is required minimum distributions, which force large taxable withdrawals from traditional accounts starting in your seventies.
The second is IRMAA, the income-based surcharge on Medicare Part B and D premiums. Cross an income threshold and your premiums jump by thousands per year, and the thresholds look back at your tax return from two years earlier.
A large conversion can itself trigger IRMAA, so timing matters. Many planners convert aggressively in their early sixties and stop two years before Medicare starts at 65, threading the needle between the two penalties.
Common Roth Conversion Mistakes
The most expensive mistake is converting without checking the bracket math. People hear that Roths are good and convert large sums in peak earning years at 32% or 35%, rates they will never see again.
The second mistake is forgetting state taxes. If you plan to retire in a no-income-tax state, converting while living in a high-tax state means paying state tax you could have avoided entirely.
The third is converting and then needing the money within five years, tripping the early withdrawal rules. The fourth is doing it all at once instead of staggering, which wastes low-bracket space. Each of these is avoidable with a calculator and a calendar.
Where Conversion Analysis Pays Off Most
Conversions shine brightest for people with a clear rate gap: high earners who will drop brackets in retirement, or low earners in a temporary dip who can convert at 10% or 12%.
They also matter for estate planning. Heirs who inherit a traditional IRA must empty it within ten years, often during their own peak earning years. A Roth inheritance arrives tax-free and does not force taxable income onto your children.
Business owners with lumpy income, early retirees bridging to Social Security, and anyone facing large future required minimum distributions all belong on the short list of people who should run the numbers every year.
How to Read Your Calculator Result
The headline verdict tells you which path wins and by roughly how much. Treat that number as a direction, not a promise: it depends on your return and rate assumptions holding true.
The three detail rows show the moving parts. The tax bill row is what you pay this April. The Roth row is your tax-free ending balance. The traditional row is the same growth minus retirement taxes.
If the advantage is small, a few hundred dollars on a six-figure conversion, treat it as a wash and decide on non-math factors like estate simplicity or protection against future tax increases. Only a clear, large advantage justifies the paperwork and the upfront tax check.
Edge Cases and Limitations
The calculator keeps the math clean by holding returns constant, but real markets bounce. A conversion right before a market drop means you paid tax on money that then shrank, though you can no longer recharacterize and undo it, so timing luck matters.
State taxes, the pro-rata rule for mixed pre-tax and after-tax IRA balances, and the interaction with Social Security taxation can all shift the real answer. The pro-rata rule in particular surprises people: you cannot convert only your after-tax contributions if your IRA also holds pre-tax money.
Finally, tax law itself is a variable. Rates, brackets, and Roth rules change with legislation. A conversion is a bet that the rules you planned under will still make sense decades from now, so revisit the decision rather than setting it once and forgetting it.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is a Roth conversion?
A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional, SEP, or SIMPLE IRA into a Roth IRA. You pay ordinary income tax on the converted amount in the year of the conversion, and from then on the money grows and can be withdrawn tax-free under the qualified distribution rules.
2. How much tax will I owe on a Roth conversion?
You owe your marginal income tax rate on the full converted amount, because the conversion stacks on top of your other income for the year. A $50,000 conversion for someone in the 22% bracket adds about $11,000 to their tax bill, and large conversions can push part of the amount into a higher bracket.
3. Is a Roth conversion worth it?
It is worth it when the tax rate you pay on the conversion is lower than the rate you would pay withdrawing the money later. Use the comparison in this guide: convert at 12% now to avoid 22% later and you win; convert at 32% now to avoid 22% later and you lose.
4. Can I undo a Roth conversion?
No. Since 2018, Roth conversions cannot be recharacterized or undone. Before the tax law change you could reverse a conversion if the market dropped, but now the decision is permanent the moment it is processed, so be sure before you convert.
5. What is the five-year rule for Roth conversions?
Each conversion starts a five-year clock. If you withdraw the converted principal before five years pass and you are under 59 and a half, a 10% early withdrawal penalty applies. After 59 and a half the penalty no longer applies, and qualified distributions of earnings are tax-free once a Roth has been open five years.
6. Should I pay the conversion tax from the IRA itself?
Almost never. Paying from outside funds keeps the full amount growing tax-free inside the Roth. Withholding tax from the conversion shrinks your Roth balance, and if you are under 59 and a half the withheld portion may also face a 10% early withdrawal penalty.
7. Does a Roth conversion affect my Medicare premiums?
Yes, potentially. The converted amount raises your modified adjusted gross income, which can push you over an IRMAA threshold and raise your Medicare Part B and D premiums two years later. Large conversions in your early sixties need to account for this surcharge.
8. Can I do a partial Roth conversion?
Yes, and partial conversions are often the smartest approach. You convert just enough each year to fill your current tax bracket without spilling into the next one, repeating the process across low-income years to move large balances at low rates.
9. How does a Roth conversion interact with required minimum distributions?
Converting shrinks your traditional balance, which shrinks your future required minimum distributions and the taxes on them. Many retirees convert in the gap years between retirement and RMD age specifically to defuse the RMD tax bomb waiting in their seventies.
10. Are there income limits on Roth conversions?
No. Anyone with a traditional, SEP, or SIMPLE IRA can convert regardless of income. This is different from direct Roth IRA contributions, which phase out above certain incomes, and it is why high earners use the backdoor Roth strategy of contributing nondeductible dollars and then converting.
11. What is the pro-rata rule?
The pro-rata rule says that when your traditional IRAs hold both pre-tax and after-tax money, any conversion is treated as a proportional mix of both. You cannot cherry-pick and convert only the after-tax dollars; the IRS treats all your traditional IRAs as one combined account for this calculation.
12. Will a Roth conversion push me into a higher tax bracket?
It can, because the converted amount is added to your taxable income for the year. This is the main argument for staggered partial conversions: you control the size of each year's conversion so it fits inside your target bracket instead of spilling over.
13. Is a Roth conversion good for estate planning?
Often yes. Heirs who inherit a traditional IRA generally must empty it within ten years, paying tax at their own rates during their peak earning years. An inherited Roth IRA still has the ten-year rule but the withdrawals are tax-free, which can save your beneficiaries a large tax bill.
14. When is the best time of year to convert?
Late in the year is usually best, because by December you know your full-year income and can size the conversion to fill your bracket precisely. Converting early in the year means guessing, which risks overshooting into a higher bracket or undershooting and wasting low-bracket space.
15. Do I need to convert all at once or can I spread it out?
You can spread it out, and most planners recommend doing exactly that. Annual partial conversions let you exploit low-income years, stay inside favorable brackets, manage IRMAA thresholds, and adjust each year as tax law and your income change.