Skip to content
Math & Scientific

Proving Identities Calculator

Proving Identities Calculator

Sweep both sides of an identity around the full circle and count every match.

Allowed: x, pi, + – * / ^, parentheses, sin cos tan sec csc cot asin acos atan sqrt cbrt abs ln log exp

Ten spot checks are good. Twenty-seven are better. When you want to be really sure that two expressions agree everywhere — not just at the angles you happened to pick — you sweep the whole circle.

The Proving Identities Calculator does exactly that. Type both sides of a claimed identity, choose how many sample points to test and how strict the match must be, and it marches around all 360 degrees comparing the two sides at every stop.

The result is a verdict backed by a full angle report: how many points matched, how many were undefined, and the largest difference found anywhere.

What Does the Proving Identities Calculator Do?

It verifies identities by dense numeric sampling. You enter the left and right sides as expressions in x, and the calculator evaluates both at evenly spaced angles around the full circle — 12, 24, or 36 points, your choice.

Three extra angles (30°, 45°, 60°) are folded in when they are not already sampled, so the classic exact-value positions are always covered.

The output is statistical: angles tested, angles matched, angles skipped as undefined, and the largest absolute difference found. A verdict banner declares the identity verified or refuted.

How to Use the Proving Identities Calculator

Type the left-hand side and right-hand side using x for the angle, with the same expression rules as the other proving calculators: standard operators, parentheses, and the trig and math function list.

Pick the sample count and the tolerance from the two dropdowns. Choose degrees or radians for the angle labels in the report.

Press Calculate for the sweep. If an expression cannot be parsed, a message names the offending side. Press Reset to start over.

The Full-Circle Sweep: 12, 24, or 36 Points

Twelve points sample every 30° — quick and usually decisive. Twenty-four points sample every 15°, the default, and catch most pathological disagreements. Thirty-six points sample every 10° for maximum thoroughness.

More points cost nothing but a moment of computation, so there is little reason to skimp. The extras at 30°, 45°, and 60° are added on top, deduplicated against the even spacing.

The sweep covers the entire circle because identities must hold in every quadrant. A surprising number of false identities behave in the first quadrant and misbehave in the third.

Choosing a Tolerance: Strict, Normal, or Loose

Strict tolerance (1e-9) demands agreement to nine decimal places — appropriate for exact identities, where any deviation is an error. Normal (1e-6) is the default and absorbs ordinary floating-point noise.

Loose (1e-3) is for approximations and engineering checks, where you want to know whether two expressions are practically equal rather than mathematically identical.

The worked near-identity example below shows all three in action on the same pair of expressions. Tolerance is not about being sloppy; it is about asking the right question.

Reading the Angle Report

Below the statistics, the angle report lists every skipped angle and every mismatching angle it found (up to eight of each, with a count for the rest).

Skipped angles are undefined points — places where a denominator hit zero or a function left its domain. They are reported so you can confirm they are genuine singularities.

Mismatches are listed with their differences in scientific notation. A difference of 1e-2 is a real disagreement; a difference of 1e-12 under strict tolerance is floating-point dust worth investigating but rarely a refutation.

Worked Example: (1 − cos x)/sin x = sin x/(1 + cos x)

First: type (1 - cos(x)) / sin(x) on the left and sin(x) / (1 + cos(x)) on the right, with 24 sample points and normal tolerance.

At 60°, the left side is (1 − 0.5) ÷ 0.8660 ≈ 0.5774, and the right side is 0.8660 ÷ 1.5 ≈ 0.5774.

Then: run the sweep. Both sides match at every testable angle, with the largest difference around 1e-16 — pure floating-point noise.

The verdict declares the identity verified. Note the skips at 0° and 180°, where sin x = 0 makes the left side undefined: genuine holes, correctly excluded.

Worked Example: tan x = sin(2x)/(1 + cos(2x))

First: type tan(x) on the left and sin(2*x) / (1 + cos(2*x)) on the right.

At 30°, the left side is tan 30° ≈ 0.5774; the right side is sin 60° ÷ (1 + cos 60°) = 0.8660 ÷ 1.5 ≈ 0.5774.

Then: the sweep verifies the identity across the circle, skipping 90° and 270° where tangent is undefined.

This is the tangent half-angle family in disguise — a useful form when you need tan expressed through double angles, and the sweep confirms it cleanly.

Worked Example: A Near-Identity Under Different Tolerances

First: type sin(x) on the left and x - x^3/6 on the right — the famous small-angle approximation — and sweep at 24 points.

At strict tolerance, several angles mismatch: near 30° the two sides differ by about 0.00033, far above 1e-9. The verdict correctly refuses to call this an identity.

Then: switch the tolerance to loose (1e-3) and run again. Now every angle matches, because the largest difference stays under a thousandth.

The lesson: strict tolerance tests mathematical identity; loose tolerance tests practical approximation. Same expressions, different questions, different answers.

Worked Example: Catching a False Identity

First: type cos(2*x) on the left and 2*cos(x) on the right — a mangled double-angle formula missing a square.

At 60°, the left side is cos 120° = −0.5, while the right side is 2 × 0.5 = 1.0. Not close.

Then: the sweep reports mismatches at nearly every sampled angle, with differences around 1.0 to 1.5.

The angle report’s mismatch list makes the failure undeniable. The correct form, 2cos²x − 1, would pass the same sweep — try it to see the contrast.

Undefined Points: Holes, Not Verdicts

Every skip in the report deserves ten seconds of thought. Ask: is this angle a genuine singularity of the expression, or did I create it by accident?

Genuine skips cluster at predictable places: multiples of 90° for tan and sec, multiples of 180° for cot and csc, and wherever your own denominators vanish.

Accidental skips come from typos — a denominator like (x − x) that is zero everywhere, for instance. If every angle is skipped, the expression is broken, and the calculator says so instead of verifying anything.

Common Proving Identities Mistakes

The biggest is entering degrees-style constants without pi. Writing sin(x + 30) shifts by 30 radians, not 30 degrees — a completely different expression that will fail the sweep mysteriously.

Another is forgetting that ^ binds to the function result: sin(x)^2 squares the sine, which is what you want, but sin(x^2) squares the angle, which is not.

People also misread the largest-difference statistic. Under normal tolerance, a max difference of 1e-7 is fine; a max difference of 1e-2 is a refutation. The exponent tells the story.

Where Full-Circle Checks Earn Their Keep

They shine on identities with messy algebra — half-angle forms, sum-to-product conversions, and expressions with nested fractions where hand-checking every quadrant is tedious.

They are also the right tool before coding. If a graphics or signal-processing routine depends on a trig simplification, a 36-point sweep takes seconds and prevents a subtle, expensive bug.

Teachers use the mismatch lists as ready-made counterexamples. “Here is exactly where your proposed identity breaks” ends debates fast.

The Limits of Sampling

Even 36 points are finitely many. A sufficiently pathological pair of expressions could agree at all samples and differ between them — though with the smooth functions allowed here, constructing such a pair is essentially impossible by accident.

Sampling also cannot explain. It tells you that (1 − cos x)/sin x equals sin x/(1 + cos x); the beautiful step — multiplying by the conjugate — remains yours to discover.

Treat the sweep as the strongest possible numeric evidence, and still write the proof. Evidence convinces; proof explains.

How to Interpret Your Result Correctly

A verified verdict with a tiny max difference (1e-12 or smaller) means the identity is as certain as numerics get. File it away and move on.

A verified verdict under loose tolerance means practical agreement, not exact identity. Do not cite it as a theorem — cite it as an approximation with a known error bound.

A refuted verdict is definitive: one genuine mismatch disproves an identity claim. Find the first mismatching angle and recompute by hand to locate the error.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How many sample points should I use?

Twenty-four is the sweet spot for most identities — dense enough to catch quadrant-specific failures, fast enough to feel instant. Twelve suffices for simple checks.

Reach for thirty-six when the expressions are complicated or when a 24-point sweep leaves you uneasy. More points never hurt.

2. What is the difference between strict and normal tolerance?

Strict (1e-9) demands agreement to nine decimals; normal (1e-6) allows six. True identities pass both easily — their differences sit around 1e-16.

Normal exists because some legitimate computations accumulate slightly more rounding error, for example through nested divisions. When in doubt, start strict and relax only with a reason.

3. When would I ever use loose tolerance?

When you are testing an approximation rather than an identity. Engineers often need to know whether a simpler expression stays within a thousandth of the true one.

The small-angle approximation example shows the pattern: loose tolerance answers “close enough for my purpose”, which is sometimes exactly the right question.

4. Why are 30°, 45°, and 60° added as extras?

They are the angles with exact, memorable trig values — the ones every textbook proof leans on. Including them guarantees the sweep covers the positions a human prover would check first.

If your sample count already lands on them (12 points hits 30° and 60°), they are deduplicated, not double-counted.

5. What does “largest difference” tell me?

It is the worst disagreement found anywhere in the sweep, in absolute terms. For a true identity it is floating-point noise around 1e-16.

Read it in scientific notation: 1e-7 is fine under normal tolerance, 1e-3 is a genuine mismatch. The exponent is the whole story.

6. The verdict says “nothing testable”. What happened?

Every sampled angle produced an undefined value on at least one side. Usually this means a typo created a permanently undefined expression, like a denominator that is always zero.

Check both expressions for division by zero or functions outside their domains, fix them, and sweep again.

7. Can a false identity pass the sweep?

In theory, yes — a function could be engineered to match at 36 specific angles and differ elsewhere. In practice, with smooth trigonometric expressions, it does not happen by accident.

The realistic failure mode is the opposite: a true identity failing under strict tolerance due to accumulated rounding in a messy expression. Normal tolerance exists for exactly that case.

8. Why does the sweep go all the way around instead of just 0° to 90°?

Because signs change by quadrant, and sign errors are the most common algebra mistakes. An identity that holds in the first quadrant can fail in the third if a sign was dropped.

The full circle costs nothing extra and closes that hole completely.

9. Do I need to worry about radians vs degrees here?

No. The sweep covers the same geometric positions either way; the toggle only changes how angles are labeled in the report.

Pick whichever unit matches your course or your intuition. The verdict is identical.

10. How is this different from the ten-angle checker?

That tool tests ten fixed angles you cannot change; this one sweeps the circle densely with adjustable count and tolerance, and reports statistics instead of a row table.

Use the ten-angle checker for quick deliberate tests, and this sweeper when you want maximum confidence or an angle report.

11. What expressions are allowed?

The variable x, the constant pi, operators + − * / ^, parentheses, and the functions sin, cos, tan, sec, csc, cot, asin, acos, atan, sqrt, cbrt, abs, ln, log, and exp.

Implicit multiplication works too: 2x and 2(x+1) are read correctly.

12. Why are some angles skipped in a verified identity?

Because the expressions are genuinely undefined there — a denominator hits zero or a function leaves its domain. The first worked example skips 0° and 180° for exactly this reason.

Skips are reported so you can confirm they sit at real singularities. They do not weaken the verdict.

13. Can I use this to check calculus identities?

For trig-heavy calculus identities, yes — the sweep does not care where the identity came from. Anything expressible with the allowed functions can be tested.

It cannot differentiate or integrate, though. It checks equality of expressions, not the steps that produced them.

14. The mismatch list shows huge differences. Is that normal?

For a false identity, yes. Wrong algebra usually produces differences of 0.1 to 2.0, not subtle ones — the worked false example shows differences around 1.0 to 1.5.

Tiny differences near the tolerance boundary deserve a second look; huge ones are simply wrong identities.

15. Should students use this before or after attempting the proof?

After the first attempt, before the final write-up. Trying the algebra first builds skill; sweeping afterward catches the slips.

Using it before attempting anything turns a learning exercise into a button-press. The struggle is where the understanding forms.